Rookie maximums for at-bats (130), games pitched (30) or innings (50) in the major leagues"

If the 2 leaders are within 5% of each other, or the leader has less than 35% there will be a run-off between the top 2. If a run-off results in a tie the tiebreaker will be vote total in the previous poll, we will continue to "go back" in the polls until there is a clear leader.
*Rosario ineligible
*Dom ineligible

P.S. don't stress too much if you feel player X deserves to be on this list vs. player Y. It's extremely unlikely someone not yet nominated would be win any given poll. Nominate those you see fit.
** Executive decision, pulled the plug early on #7. By having the polls begin in the morning it allows for a more lively discussion. Lindsay was running away with the vote.

1) Andres Gimenez (SS) 12/27 votes-44%
2) David Peterson (LHP) 12/24 votes-50%
3) Mark Vientos (SS/3B) 13/24 votes-54%
4) Peter Alonso (1B) 21/28 votes-75%
5) Thomas Szapucki (LHP) 10/22-45%
6) Justin Dunn (RHP) 4/20-20%, runoff with Lindsay/Guillorme/Kay 9/22-41%
7) Desmond Lindsay (OF) 12/26-46%

Mauricio next...?

Nomination noted.

Jeff
12:20 Rosario & Smith: Growing pains or red flags?
Eric A Longenhagen
12:20 The former.

Sammy
12:28 Is Luis Guillorme possibly an underrated prospect? Does he get picked in the rule V if not put on 40 this offseason?
Eric A Longenhagen
12:29 I think his glove could help a team right now, yeah.

One of these things is not like the other.

Yes, I think Rosario has high upside, but need reps to work on his batting approach. Smith I see more red flags possibly, though I also saw more upside than I thought was there when I saw him in the minors.

Mostly I think Rosario is ready, Smith should spend another season in AAA. Smith could still be a high average guy with power though, like a mini Mo Vaughn. I wouldn't want to give up on him yet, either.

Yeah, Smith would prob benefit from having more time in AAA. I don't know if it will happen though.

Smith would also benefit from taking his off-season seriously and then taking that diet into the season with him. Any argument regarding "he's not out of shape" or "he's fine!" went out the door. One of the more out of shape Mets I can recall in recent years.

Can I nominate Colin Holderman to be removed from the poll? Just noticing now he's even on the list.

HeyNowHK nominated him.

Oh OK. Don't mind anyone as long as someone is going to vote for them. May need a rule before long that guys get cycled off after 2 times with no votes, though. Once you get past about #15 especially, there are going to be lots of possibilities without a lot separating them.