Rookie maximums for at-bats (130), games pitched (30) or innings (50) in the major leagues"

If the 2 leaders are within 5% of each other, or the leader has less than 35% there will be a run-off between the top 2. If a run-off results in a tie the tiebreaker will be vote total in the previous poll, we will continue to "go back" in the polls until there is a clear leader.
*Rosario ineligible
*Dom ineligible

P.S. don't stress too much if you feel player X deserves to be on this list vs. player Y. It's extremely unlikely someone not yet nominated would be win any given poll. Nominate those you see fit.
** Executive decision, pulled the plug early on #7. By having the polls begin in the morning it allows for a more lively discussion. Lindsay was running away with the vote. Same with #10. Poll #11 will only have 9 options, I accidently had Kay listed a second time (copy and paste, sue me lol)

1) Andres Gimenez (SS) 12/27 votes-44%
2) David Peterson (LHP) 12/24 votes-50%
3) Mark Vientos (SS/3B) 13/24 votes-54%
4) Peter Alonso (1B) 21/28 votes-75%
5) Thomas Szapucki (LHP) 10/22-45%
6) Justin Dunn (RHP) 4/20-20%, runoff with Lindsay/Guillorme/Kay 9/22-41%
7) Desmond Lindsay (OF) 12/26-46%
Luis Guillorme (SS) 8/25-32%, run-off with Kay 11/22-50%, advances due to more votes in previous poll
9) Anthony Kay (LHP) 9/24-38%, run-off with Bashlor 10/20-50%, advances due to more votes in previous poll
10) Tyler Bashlor (RHP) 11/16-69%
11) Tomas Nido (C) 6/24-25%, run-off with Molina and Oswalt 12/20 60%
12) Marcos Molina (RHP) 6/20-30%, run-off with Evans 13/20-65%
13) Ronny Mauricio (SS) 6/17-35%
14) Gavin Cecchini (2B) 6/23-26%, run-off with Mazeika 12/15-80%
15) Chris Flexen (RHP) 8/26-31%, run-off with Mazeika/Thompson 8/11-73%
16) Patrick Mazeika (C) 6/22-27%, run-off with Thompson 8/14-57%
17) Corey Oswalt (RHP) 6/21-29%, run-off with Thompson 10/18-56%
18) David Thompson (3B) 8/21-38%
19) Jordan Humphreys (RHP) 9/16-56%
20) Kevin Kaczmarski (OF) 5/14-36%
21)Gerson Bautista (RHP) 5/24-21%, run-off with Evans 11/19-58%
22) Phil Evans (UTIL) 6/17-35%
23) Juan Uriarte (C) 6/19-32%
24) Drew Smith (RHP) 6/21-29%, run-off with Uceta 11/18-61%
25) Adonis Uceta (RHP) 9/20-45%
26) Jamie Callahan (RHP) 3/14-21%, Runoff with Holderman/Conlon 9/16-56%
27) PJ Conlon 6/16-38%
28) Nabil Crismatt 4/14-29%, Runoff with Holderman 10/17-59%
29) Colin Holderman 3/14-21%, Runoff with Blackham 7/13-54%
30) Matt Blackham 5/18 28%, Runoff with Becerra 9/13-69%
31) Steven Villines 3/15-20%, runoff with Becerra/James/Brodey 6/15-40%
32) Adrian Hernandez 3/17-18%, Run off with Becerra/James/Brodey 4/11-36%
33) Jhoan Urena (1b/3B) 3/16-19%, runoff with James 6/11-55%
34) Christian James (RHP) 4/16-25%, runoff with Nogosek 7/12-58%

Nogo before McGeorge?

Yeah, McGeorge is probably better. Same draft, a round apart, and McGeorge performed at the higher level. And his slider gives him a shot to be a useful pen arm.

Steve Matz should take lessons from McGeorge on how to keep the ball down. McGeorge looks like a grounder machine...

BTW I voted for McNeil.....

McGeorge signed 7th round for $175 K in a 187 slot. 220th overall.
Nogo signed 6th round, 220 K in a 250 slot, 178th overall . . . so, that's a wash.

Boston used Nogo as a closer in A/A+ this year. His numbers were much better in A than A+. He's got more velocity and a "max effort" delivery that this writer thinks is an injury waiting to happen and he has some issues with control, but he hides the ball well at times, and uses 2 pitches well. The boston writer says he'd rank him higher if he didn't see an injury waiting to happen.

McGeorge has better stats and it's not even very close and his draft writeup says he has a potential plus slider.

I guess it depends on if you're a stats guy for the slower thrower with better control or a velocity/live arm guy with less control.

Nogo:

http://prospects1500.com/top-50-lists/b ... ects-2017/

http://metsminors.net/scouting-the-thre ... ison-reed/

McGeorge:

https://www.amazinavenue.com/2016/6/22/ ... n-mcgeorge

I'd like to know more about McGeorge, but nobody seems to do detailed write-ups anymore - maybe under subscription. Any subscribers have any thoughts?

I considered making a list of possibles, but it's like 20 names long. Either I'm overestimating, or I think the Mets have some nice depth in the 40-60 range. A handful of guys with a shot at making it into the 30-50 range this time next year. (joking aside - I like our depth in the 30-60 region.

Here it is, my - these guys should all get nominated before we're done, list (in no particular order)

Knapp
Rasquin
Regnault
Jannis
Bradford and McGowan – they held onto their 40 man spots. Both overlooked
Corey Taylor
Tim Peterson
Patkin, Max.
Dimino (hits)
Zanghi (has some velocity)
The other Gonzalez
Ryder Ryan (the forgotten pickup)
Andrew Church (the other overlooked, I think he's due for a bashloresq breakout next year)
Carpio even if his stock is down he's still a doing OK for the level. Youngest guy in Columbia not named Gimenez and he lead the team in walks.
Rhame (he’s on the 40 guys)
Winaker (I like 15 walks to 11 Ks, especially when nobody hits in Brooklyn)
Hansel Moreno
Dirocie
Lagrange
Terrazas
Jose Medina
Trey “Funky” Cobb
Acosta

I don't know how I'm going to nominate 23 guys for 15 remaining nominee spots but I'm going to try. (sorry Metro).