#11 Run-off Nido vs. Oswalt vs. Molina?

MaxV · **Joined:** Sat May 16, 2009 7:02 pm **Posts:** 593

Nido is my pick.

On the surface, he might be just a meh prospect, but if you look deeper into his upside relative to his position, he is interesting.

HeyNowHK · **Posted:** Tue Oct 17, 2017 4:30 pm

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Metro2007 · **Posted:** Tue Oct 17, 2017 4:49 pm

Nido 0-2 so far today, no other Mets have appeared

Ralf · **Joined:** Tue Jul 10, 2012 7:03 pm **Posts:** 7778

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Not nearly as depressing as Guillorme at 8.

HeyNowHK · **Posted:** Tue Oct 17, 2017 5:37 pm

Ralf wrote:

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Not nearly as depressing as Guillorme at 8.

That was depressing too. I was trying not to go back too far... :lol:

MarkJohnson>You · **Joined:** Fri Feb 01, 2008 3:56 pm **Posts:** 60428

Ralf wrote:

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Not nearly as depressing as Guillorme at 8.

5 years from now, when the next "advanced approach" middle infielder with a good glove dominates the lowest levels of the system and everyone goes nuts, we'll have Guillorme to say "Hey, remember when he was a prospect and then everyone spent the 3 years after he was added to the 40 man screaming for him to be DFA'ed?" the way we do with Tejada now.

So at least we have that to look forward to.

HeyNowHK · **Posted:** Tue Oct 17, 2017 5:50 pm

MarkJohnson>You wrote:

Ralf wrote:

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Not nearly as depressing as Guillorme at 8.

5 years from now, when the next "advanced approach" middle infielder with a good glove dominates the lowest levels of the system and everyone goes nuts, we'll have Guillorme to say "Hey, remember when he was a prospect and then everyone spent the 3 years after he was added to the 40 man screaming for him to be DFA'ed?" the way we do with Tejada now.

So at least we have that to look forward to.

He might actually make some people forget about Tejada...

Hot Takes · **Joined:** Sat Sep 09, 2017 3:38 pm **Posts:** 198

Guillorme should never reach Tejada levels of hate because there's no scenario in which Guillorme is our starting SS for 3+ years.

And Guillorme's glove is better than Tejada's ever was so I don't think it's a stretch to say Guillorme shouldn't be sweating his spot on a 40, whether it's ours or someone else's, considering we're probably internally debating between Evans, Reynolds, and Cecchini right now.

LTKfRGM · **Posted:** Tue Oct 17, 2017 6:58 pm

Hot Takes wrote:

Guillorme should never reach Tejada levels of hate because there's no scenario in which Guillorme is our starting SS for 3+ years.

And Guillorme's glove is better than Tejada's ever was so I don't think it's a stretch to say Guillorme shouldn't be sweating his spot on a 40, whether it's ours or someone else's, considering we're probably internally debating between Evans, Reynolds, and Cecchini right now.

I remember when we liked Tejada.

MaxV · **Joined:** Sat May 16, 2009 7:02 pm **Posts:** 593

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

He would be 25th best in some systems.

dragonfly · **Joined:** Mon May 21, 2007 12:17 pm **Posts:** 6234

Ralf wrote:

HeyNowHK wrote:

He's prob interesting as a 25th best prospect in a system. At 11 it's depressing. And after a RP easily locks up 10, and a guy who won't have thrown a pitch before he turns 23 at 9.

I'm looking for a needle in the haystack to emerge from the depths next season.

Not nearly as depressing as Guillorme at 8.

Pretty depressing. A guy that would be lucky to be the next Ruben Tejada if everything goes right for him.

Nido will be lucky to be the next Josh Thole.

This is the state of the system.

#11 Run-off Nido vs. Oswalt vs. Molina?

Who is online